1911, North Carolina Appalachians The Horrifying Story of Nathaniel Burke

Welcome to this trip through one of the scariest cases in US history.

Leave a comment below telling us where you are watching us right now.

The story we’re about to tell takes place in the dark mountains of North Carolina more than a 100red years ago.

No one has been able to fully explain what happened to Nathaniel Burke up to this point.

The year is 1911.

The Appalachian Mountains were still a place where modern life had not fully spread out yet.

Dirt.

The roads wound their way between deep valleys and misty peaks.

At that time, whole communities lived alone in North Carolina for weeks at a time.

The silence of the forests held secrets that would never make it to the big city newspapers.

It was a world apart, and it had its own set of unwritten rules.

Nathaniel Burke left his life in Richmond, Virginia when he was 32 years old to see what the mountains in the south had to offer.

His job was as a clerk and a railroad company hired him to help them build more tracks through the Appalachian.

A well-educated, careful man who wrote in great detail about his travels.

His records were very accurate, almost like science.

Everything was written down.

temperatures, rock formations, meeting locals, and every stream he crossed.

It’s funny that that habit is the only reason we know for sure that terrible things happened in those mountains.

Nathaniel left Asheville in March of that year with enough food for 3 weeks.

They were going to Madison County, more specifically a remote area close to thee.

The the town of Shelton Laurel is famous for its deep caves and dangerous canyons.

He planned to make a map of possible railroad routes, look for natural tunnels, and check how stable the land was.

While Nathaniel liked being alone, he had to do the work.

Ezra Whitlock was the only local guide he hired.

He knew every trail in that area like the back of his hand.

Nathaniel’s diary says that the first few days went as planned.

In March, it was cold and the trees still didn’t have any leaves on them.

There are full leaves and the sound of water running through the canyons all the time.

Ezra was a good guide, but he wasn’t very good at talking to people.

After 5 days, they came across an empty hut on top of a hill.

Nathaniel saw that the place looked like it was left quickly.

Dishes were all over the place, and there was still a pot on the stove.

Clothes that were hanging there were already rotting from the humidity.

Ezra didn’t want to go inside.

He only told them to leave because that place had bad stories.

But Nathaniel was a scientist.

He was naturally interested in things.

He looked around the cabin while Ezra waited outside looking angry.

Nathaniel wrote in his diary that he saw strange marks on the inside walls.

He said they looked like primitive symbols carved deep into the wood, making patterns that I can’t figure out.

In his notebook, he drew pictures of these signs.

He also said that he found a hidden space under the floorboards, but he didn’t say what was inside.

“I have found something that Ezra needs to know,” was all he wrote.

“See, I don’t think this hut was just left empty.

” The tone of the diary changes after that.

Nathaniel’s notes get shorter and more hurried.

On the sixth day, he writes that Ezra is acting strangely by looking back at them all the time while they walk and insisting that they should leave the mountains right away.

Nathaniel said that the company expected him to get things done and that he still had work to do.

What Nathaniel wrote in quotation marks is something that Ezra would have answered.

There are It’s not possible to see everything on a map, and smart people don’t go to these mountain spots.

something took place on the seventh day.

The record is messy and hard to understand.

As Nathaniel writes, he says that he heard voices coming from the valley below the night before.

However, these voices were not normal.

They had an echo that didn’t sound natural, like it came from inside the land.

By morning, Ezra was no longer there.

His gun, groceries, and other things were still in the camp, but he wasn’t there.

no longer.

Nathaniel looked for them all day by calling them and following the trails around the camp.

Nothing.

It looked like the forest had swallowed up Ezra, leaving Nathaniel all by himself.

He made a terrible choice.

He didn’t go downstairs right away to get help.

He chose to keep going.

We don’t know if she was being stubborn at work, afraid to leave a man who might be hurt somewhere, or doing something else that the diary doesn’t make clear, but he kept going into even more remote parts of Appalachia.

These are his notes from the next days.

He felt like he was being watched more and more, finding strange footprints and hearing sounds he couldn’t place.

Nathaniel found another building on the 10th day.

He says it looked like a stone shrine built against the side of a cliff and partly hidden by plants.

It wasn’t a hut.

It was inside that he found disturbing things such as bones arranged in circles.

Stones stained with something dark and more of those symbols engraved.

This time not just on wood, but also on stone carved right into the rock.

Nathaniel was starting to realize that he was on to something much bigger than a simple mapping trip.

The most recent full entry in the diary was made on March 23rd, 1911.

In his letter, Nathaniel says that he has finally decided to go back and tell the authorities what he saw.

He says that something bad happened in the mountains and may still be happening.

He says that he kept proof, which were small things that he got from the stone shrine.

He’s going to go down in the morning.

He will follow a stream until he gets to the main road.

Then the introduction ends quickly with a disturbing sentence.

There are steps outside my tent.

They are not animal parts.

In 6 weeks, a fur trapper named Thomas Hargrove found Nathaniel Burke’s diary while following deer trails in Madison County, which is close by.

When Thomas was checking his traps, he saw something strange.

Tears in the fabric were stuck in thorny bushes, making a rough path that led down to a narrow valley.

He was interested and a little scared.

He kept following the tracks until he found a leather backpack partially buried in wet leaves and broken branches.

the diary, some measuring tools, a partially finished map, and a small canvas bag with strange things in it that Thomas would later described to the sheriff as being there for no reason at all, stood out.

When Thomas took the diary to Marshall, which is the county seat of Madison County, the police at first thought it was just an accident while Thomas was exploring.

Men from the city were people who went into those mountains by themselves often disappeared.

Appalachians did not forget about mistakes.

If you take one wrong step, you could fall into a canyon and die.

Even the most experienced explorers could get lost in an unexpected storm.

There were still a lot of black bears in the area.

Most of the time, the easiest explanation was the right one.

Sheriff Edmund Callaway, who had been a federal marshal before moving to that quiet county, was not happy with simple explanations, though.

He he read the whole diary page by page and what he found there really upset him.

It wasn’t the technical notes about the land or the railroad routes that interested him.

It was the last few entries which talked about abandoned huts, strange symbols, and hidden stone structures.

Edmund was familiar with the hills.

He grew up there, so he knew the stories that his elders told in low voices, stories that most people didn’t want to hear.

Edmund put together a search party of 12 men, including Thomas Harve, to lead the search.

They went to the spot where the backpack was found.

They left early in the morning in May when it was foggy.

Spring had already covered the mountains with thick foliage.

It took 3 days for the group to just get to the general area that Nathaniel wrote about in his journal.

The trails were dangerous, and they would often disappear completely into the bushes.

Men thought about giving up and going back more than once, but Edmund wouldn’t let them.

He couldn’t quite put his finger on what in that diary made him feel bad.

They found the on the fourth day of their search, Nathaniel Burke’s first clear sign.

It was a camp that had been partially taken apart in a small clearing surrounded by tall pine trees.

The tent was still there, but it was torn in several places, and the stakes seemed to have been pulled hard from the ground.

A few meters around, kitchen tools were spread out in different places.

It was loaded and propped up against a tree, but Nathaniel had never fired it.

It had rained for weeks, and his extra clothes were wet and partly covered in moss.

But there was no body, no blood, and no clear signs of a fight.

Just that scene of sudden chaos.

The men looked all around the camp.

They found something scary about 50 yards away.

It was a farmer named William Jessup.

The tracks were not like other footprints.

William called everyone to come see him.

The shapes of the marks on the wet ground looked like they were made by a person, but they were too big and out of proportion.

And the depth of the mark suggested that the person was much heavier than usual.

That was even worse.

The footprints looked like.

It looks like something watched the camp for hours before taking action by going around it several times.

They were told to follow the footprints by Edmund.

They followed the marks that led them down the mountain through a forest that kept getting thicker until they reached a narrow canyon with a stream running between rocks covered in lyanthropy.

They found Nathaniel’s second piece of gear, his tool belt, still with all of its instruments attached.

It was in a bend in the creek where the water formed a small dark well.

The leather looked like it had been ripped by force.

James Porter, one of the men on the expedition who had fought in the war against Spain many years before, looked at the belt and quietly said that this kind of damage could not have been caused by animals or accidents.

It was something that was planned and had a lot of force.

Edmund chose something.

One half of the group was told to go back to Marshall with more people, supplies, and if possible, an experienced tracker from outside the area.

Also in the other half are he would keep looking for it himself.

They had to find something in those mountains, and with each hour that went by, their chances of figuring out what had really happened to Nathaniel Burke, and most likely Ezra Whitlock lost hope.

The men agreed, though it was clear that some of them would rather just go down.

Attention was in the air that no one could quite put their finger on, but that everyone could feel.

As the six men made their way back to normal life, Edmund and the other five kept looking.

They went upstream along the stream because Nathaniel wrote in his journal that he had camped near running water more than once.

The land got rougher and wilder as they moved forward.

Some of the trees were so big that three men couldn’t hug them hand in hand because they were so old.

The thick canopy of leaves made it hard for the sun to get through.

Strangely, the sound of the stream echoed off the rocky walls of the valley, making a cacophony of watery murmurss that seemed to be coming from everywhere, to come from everywhere at once.

Thomas Harrove, the hunter who found the first backpack, was the first person to see it.

He stopped suddenly on the path, raised his hand to ask them to be quiet, and pointed up to the face of a cliff to their right that rose almost straight up.

The others didn’t see what he had seen for a short time.

There was a building that was partly hidden by plants and vines that grew out of cracks in the rock.

It didn’t make sense.

A kind of low wall was made by stones that had been piled up on purpose against the side of the cliff.

The stone shrine was just like Nathaniel had written about it in his journal.

It wasn’t easy to get there.

The men had to use exposed roots and rocky ledges to climb.

They were taking risks that could have killed them if they fell.

But Edmund was determined.

Everyone was quiet for a long time when they finally got to the building.

The space was only about 3 m wide and 2 m deep, making it look like an artificial cave cut into the solid rock.

Inside the bones were arranged in circles just like Nathaniel had written down.

They were.

It was clear right away that those weren’t human bones.

Deer, bears, and what looked like something from a big cat were among them.

But they were not put together in a natural way.

It was made on purpose by someone or something.

There were pictures and words all over the walls of the cave.

Edmund knew of no native tribe that those things represented, even though he had lived all his life in that area and interacted with the few Cherokee who still lived in the mountains.

These were different, maybe older or completely made up.

Straight lines and curves twisted and turned into patterns that seemed to mean something but couldn’t be understood.

A Methodist minister named Reverend Samuel Yates was one of the men who said a prayer in a low voice when he saw the signs.

According to him, it looked like something dirty that shouldn’t be in a Christian country.

Edmund found something that made his blood run cold in the middle of the grotto, half buried under a thin layer of dirt and dry leaves.

It was a small book with dark leather pages, yellowed from water.

He did not already have Nathaniel’s diary in his hands.

This one was very old and different.

There was a lot of тιԍнт, shaky handwriting all over the pages.

The writing was in English, but the spelling was very old-fashioned, making it look like the book was written many years ago, maybe even in the last hundred years.

In the dim light that came into the grotto, Edmund carefully turned the pages, trying to figure out what they said.

What he read there was never.

The public knows everything about it.

Edmund kept the book for himself and only gave pieces of it to some state officials weeks later.

However, the five men who were with him at the time and saw his face change as he read each page.

They all said the same thing later.

It was clear that the sheriff was upset.

He felt his hands start to shake a little.

He quickly shut the book, put it in his own backpack, and told everyone to get down right away.

He didn’t give any reasons.

All he said was that they had to leave to get out of there before it got dark, but they couldn’t.

Even in the middle of the day, the downhill climb was dangerous, and the sun was already setting between the mountain peaks.

He chose to set up camp right there at the base of the cliff, close to the stream.

Two tents were set up, a big fire was lit, and each man watched over the camp at night.

Nobody had a good night’s sleep.

Reverend Yates read his Bible by the campfire for hours, moving his lips in silent prayer.

Thomas Hargrove didn’t give up his gun.

Always close by, his eyes were fixed on the darkness beyond the circle of light.

Edmund did nothing but stare at the flames and touch his backpack every so often to feel the mysterious book.

When he was on watch around 3:00 a.

m.

, William Jessup woke everyone up with a loud whisper.

He had heard something.

The sounds were coming from the direction of the stone shrine above them, but he couldn’t say what they were.

It could be pᴀss or something being dragged over the rocks.

There were no men around.

They were so quiet that they barely dared to breathe.

They were listening, trying to make out any sounds other than the steady murmur of the stream and the crackling of the fire.

Even though it was far away and stuffy, there was definitely something heavy moving up there as small avalanches of rocks rolled down the canyon.

Edmund turned his flashlight toward the edge of the cliff.

It took a moment for everyone to believe they saw something, but the beam of light barely reached the shrine’s height.

In one way, a that wasn’t a clear silhouette, but it was there, standing on the edge of the stone structure and watching them.

The form then went away too quickly for it to be natural.

It did not make any noise as it moved backwards into the cave’s shadows.

The silence that followed was even scarier than the sounds that came before it.

That night, no one went back to sleep.

The men kept adding fuel to the fire until it burned so H๏τ that it was almost painful.

This kept a large circle of light around the camp.

Low voices came from them telling stories about those mountains that they had heard over the years.

There are stories of travelers who vanished without a trace, of whole towns that disappeared overnight, leaving behind houses full of things, and of strange sounds resonating through the valleys at night when there was no moon.

People had always thought of those stories as silly supersтιтions or stories meant to scare kids.

That night, though, under that cliff, none of those stories seem so crazy.

When the sun goes down, when the sun finally came up, bringing with it the morning fog that always hung over the Appalachian valleys, the men hurried down the hill.

The search was no longer being talked about.

There was silence around them as everyone agreed they needed to leave that place.

Edmund led the way and marched so fast that there wasn’t much time to rest.

They got back to Marshall in 2 days, half as long as it had taken them to get there.

They were dirty, tired, and clearly shaken when they got to town and found the party that had.

They came down earlier and were waiting for them with 15 other volunteer men and even a reporter from the Asheville newspaper, who had heard about the strange case of the missing pH๏τographer.

Edmund wouldn’t talk to the reporter right away.

First, he went straight to the office of Albert Morrison, the county judge.

Morrison was a respected man who was also the highest court in the area.

Edmund was locked up with the judge for 3 hours by himself.

No one is sure what was talked about at that meeting.

But Judge Morrison looked just as upset as Edmund when they left.

He called a meeting of the mayor, the lead pastor, the local doctor, and some powerful land owners as soon as possible.

That same night, the meeting took place in the county courthouse behind closed doors.

There was an official decision made at that meeting.

There would be a new expedition planned, but this time with permission from the government, enough money and trained men.

The search for a lost explorer would not be easy.

It that part of the mountains would be thoroughly looked into.

In carefully chosen words, Judge Morrison wrote a telegram to North Carolina Governor William Kiton about what was going on.

He talked about the two men who went missing, the scary discoveries, and the need to find out what was going on in that remote area.

The message was sent that very same night.

3 days later, the governor’s answer came.

He gave the order for the expedition and said that 10 men would be sent from.

There will be help from the state militia and a special investigator from the capital.

A man named Henry Blackwood was the investigator.

He was known for being able to solve difficult cases involving crimes and missing persons in rural areas.

When Henry got to Marshall on June 12th, 1911, he brought with him cameras, forensic measuring tools, and even a simple sound recorder that he planned to use to record witnesses.

Henry Blackwood had a plan.

He spent a whole week talking to everyone involved.

He told Thomas Hargrove where and how he found Nathaniel’s packed bag.

He asked Edmund Callaway a lot of questions about what he had seen and found.

He carefully read Nathaniel’s diary page by page and took notes.

He also asked to see the strange book that Edmund had found in the stone shrine.

Edmund hesitated, but in the end he spoke.

He studied the book for two nights in his room at the nearby boarding house after getting it, lit by a lamp.

When Henry finally told everyone what he had found so far, it was both interesting and scary.

He said that the old book looked like it had been written by a group of people who lived in those mountains many years ago, maybe in the early 1800s.

It was like a diary or record of their lives.

The writings were often broken up and hard to understand.

But they talked about beliefs, rituals, and practices that did not fit with any known religion or tradition.

His report used the word cult, one by itself.

Cult that had formed in the middle of Appalachia, out of sight of most people, and did things that he didn’t want to go into too much detail in his official papers.

What really scared Henry Blackwood about his analysis wasn’t what was in the old book, but what was in the last few pages.

Someone had written more notes there using a very different and much more recent ink.

The writing was shaky and almost desperate, and the dates matched the last days written down in Nathaniel.

Burke’s writing.

Henry was able to figure out some words.

They’re still here.

The symbols are there to warn you, not to look nice.

Ezra knew, which is why he ran away.

Another scary thing is that they’re not stories.

They’re records.

Nathaniel’s handwriting was on the last note, which was written with a hand that seemed to be shaking.

It only said, “If anyone finds this, do not go up at night.

” In a private meeting, Henry told Judge Morrison and Sheriff Callaway what he had found.

He came up with a theory that was logical, but it also raised a lot of questions.

Henry said there was proof that a small isolated group, possibly related to or continuing the cult from long ago, still lived in the mountainous areas that were the farthest away.

Through generations, they would have created their own culture that is very different from modern society.

Nathaniel found an abandoned hut, a stone shrine, and symbols carved into the stone.

All of these things pointed to a hidden community.

What happened to Henry told Nathaniel Burke and Ezra Whitlock that he had no idea what was going on.

Because Ezra was from the area and might know about ancient stories, he may have seen the danger and run away when Nathaniel started to explore places that were meant to be left alone.

Or maybe he knew something about the people who lived in the mountains and was like a guardian who kept curious outsiders away.

When it came to Nathaniel, Henry thought he had found something that the secret society thought was holy or not allowed.

It was still unknown what happened next, like if he was caught, killed, or just got lost while trying to escape.

The last expedition was planned to start in early July.

There were a total of 25 men.

10 from the state militia, Edmund Callaway and five local volunteers, Henry Blackwood and his two ᴀssistants, and seven porters hired to carry supplies and equipment.

It was the biggest search operation that had ever been done in that part of North Carolina.

They brought enough tents for 2 weeks, food, weapons, and climbing gear.

They brought cameras and even explosives in case they had to fight their way through areas blocked by landslides or too much vegetation.

The trip began on a clear, warm morning on July 6th, 1911.

About half of the people who lived in Marshall came out to see them leave.

Some were hoping to finally get answers, while others looked worried and whispered prayers.

A local old woman named Mother Thornton is said to have talked to Henry Blackwood before he left.

Henry wrote this down in his notebook as an interesting local myth.

Someone had whispered in his ear, “The mountains hold what the mountains take.

You won’t find what you’re looking for, but you’ll find something.

” Without putting too much stock in the words, the first 5 days went by without any major events.

The group took the same paths Edmund and the others had taken before.

They first went to the site of Nathaniel’s destroyed camp, and then to the gorge, where the tool belt was found, emerged.

Henry carefully took pictures of everything, measured distances, and took samples of the soil and fabric.

A full dossier was being put together so that he could show it to the state’s authorities as solid proof.

The militia set up a fortified base camp near the creek.

Guards were stationed in 4-hour shifts, and campfires burned all night.

They got to the cliff with the stone shrine on the sixth day, this time with more men and the right tools.

It was safer to climb.

Henry went up the stairs.

Edmund and three militia soldiers were with them.

They had left the shrine exactly the same way they had found it weeks before.

It looked like the bones were still arranged in circles.

No one had touched the signs on the walls.

There was something new, though.

There was now something else in the middle of the grotto where Edmund had found the old book.

Of course, it was Nathaniel’s sketchbook.

That’s where he had drawn the symbols he saw in the first empty hut.

The notebook was open on a certain page that had been placed there on purpose.

Scene.

Along with the symbols, someone had written a message in simple English and charcoal.

Leave.

Men started to argue about the discovery right away.

Some people said this proved there were real people living in those mountains.

People who knew they were there and wanted to scare them.

Others who were more tense told them to heed the warning and get off right away.

Henry kept his cool and looked at the writing.

Nathaniel’s handwriting was more simple.

But this was different.

Formed by someone who clearly didn’t know how to write well.

This made his idea of an isolated community stronger.

He decided that they would keep going, but they would be more careful this time.

The number of night guards was raised from two to four per shift and they were all told to keep their guns loaded and ready.

Set up again at the base of the cliff that night.

There was no action.

Nothing out of the ordinary was heard or seen in the shadows.

The normaly of the silence was almost too much to bear.

The men began to chill out.

Some people even joked that the warning might have scared the person who left it instead of the other way around.

But Edmund was still not sure.

He knew those mountains well enough to know that being completely quiet wasn’t always a good thing.

When animals that come out at night were completely quiet, it was usually because there was something bigger and more dangerous nearby.

On the seventh day, Henry split the group up.

Half of them would stay at base camp to keep it safe and easy to defend.

also in the other half are along with Edmund and the more experienced militia soldiers.

He would go around the area in circles looking for more buildings, signs of living, or any clues about where Nathaniel and Ezra were.

They always stuck together in groups of at least five men, making sure they never got too far away from the signal sH๏τs in case something went wrong.

The most important discovery was made by the group led by Edmund about 2 miles from base camp on a hunting trail that was hard to see and wound around.

As they went through a very dense forest, they saw clear signs of recent human activity.

There wasn’t a cabin or any other permanent structure there.

Instead, there were a group of short-term shelters made from branches, leaves, and bark that were skillfully disguised to blend in with their surroundings.

There were charred remains of old fires, boiled animal bones, and even stone and wood tools from the Stone Age.

It wasn’t that long ago that someone was there.

Edmund carefully looked at the shelters.

He thought that they might be able to fit about 10 to 15 people.

But the most disturbing thing was how the place was set up.

All six of the shelters faced the same spot, which was a big flat rock in the middle of the clearing.

The rock was stained with something dark that looked like old blood, but it was impossible to be sure without further testing.

Small white stones were carefully placed around the rock to make more of those symbols in the ground.

A 23-year-old soldier named Robert Lee, whose father fought in the Civil War, found something near one of the shelters, hidden under a pile of leaves.

It was a torn piece of fabric that had changed color over time and from being in the sun and rain.

Edmund looked at him closely and felt his stomach get тιԍнт.

That shirt Nathaniel Burke wore when he left Asheville was made of the same material, according to what the railroad company that hired him said.

A strong cotton fabric in a certain shade of navy blue that was popular among professionals who worked outside.

There was no question.

Edmund told everyone to in that area look for more proof.

The men spread out in the clearing and looked in every bunker and corner for possible hiding places.

They found more.

Even more clues were found when a brᴀss ʙuттon that could have been from Nathaniel’s waste coat was found along with one of the measuring tools on the CTgraphers’s list.

A small pocket the light that was used to measure angles.

The lens was broken, but it was clear that it was a professional surveyor’s tool.

Nathaniel had been there in that spot at some point between the last entry in his diary and now.

But there was no body, no human bones, and no clear sign that someone had died.

Only these few pieces of belongings were scattered around as if they had been left behind or thrown away on purpose.

When Henry Blackwood got to the scene 2 hours after being called by signal sH๏τs, he stood there quietly for a long time just watching and trying to figure out what might have happened.

The first thing he thought was, “That’s weird.

” And Nathaniel Burke was taken there against his will.

This place had been used for some kind of ritual or judgment.

Henry told a lot of pictures to be taken of the site.

every shelter, sign, and thing that was found.

He planned to write down everything with scientific accuracy, so that there would be a record that couldn’t be questioned or brushed off as the work of crazy men.

He walked around the clearing while Frederick Walsh, his careful main ᴀssistant, worked on the camera.

He was a man of logic who was trained to find logical explanations.

He took measurements, made notes, and drew pictures.

He tried to deny it, but even he couldn’t.

He had a growing feeling that they were on to something much bigger than a simple crime.

He called a meeting of all the men on the expedition that night back at base camp.

He talked about what he had found that day and showed the pieces of clothing, the measuring tool, and pH๏τographs that had already been developed in a small portable dark tent.

Then he asked a direct question.

Did anyone know of any small towns in the mountains that were off the grid? Had anyone heard specific stories about groups that lived away from everyone else? The local men looked at each other in a strange way.

No one wanted to be the first to speak.

Reverend Yates was the one who finally spoke up.

He told a story that his own grandfather had told him decades earlier about a group of people who had settled in those mountains even before the War of Independence.

They were not natives, but they were not ordinary settlers either.

They were, according to history, religious refugees from Europe.

People who had fled persecution and were looking for a place where they could practice their beliefs without interference.

But his beliefs, the Reverend’s grandfather said, were not Christian.

They were something much older, much darker.

And as the generations pᴀssed, isolated from the outside world, these people would have become something different, something that was no longer completely human in behavior and custom.

Other local men confirmed that they had heard similar versions of that story.

Some attributed it to Europeans, others to descendants of settlers who had gone mad with isolation.

There were variations, but the core remained the same.

There was or had been a group deep in Appalachia that deliberately avoided contact with the outside world and that reacted violently when their privacy was invaded.

Most of the inhabitants of the region simply avoided certain areas of the mountains, respecting invisible borders that had been pᴀssed down from generation to generation through veiled advice and warnings.

Henry listened attentively, making notes in his notebook.

When everyone was done, he remained silent for a moment, organizing his thoughts.

Then he made a statement that surprised many present.

He believed that stories had a foundation in reality.

There was enough evidence to conclude that some human group inhabited those mountains permanently or semi-permanmanently.

But he also believed that this group was made up of flesh and blood people, not ghosts or demons.

and if they were people, they could be found, confronted, and if necessary, brought to justice for any crime they had committed.

The expedition would continue.

However, Henry established new rules.

No one would stray from the main group in less than eight men.

Everyone would be armed at all times.

Signal fires would be kept at strategic points for guidance in case someone got lost.

And more importantly, they would not remain in the region after dark unless absolutely necessary.

Each day after completing their exploration, they would return to base camp before dusk.

It was a military protocol adapted to the circumstances and everyone agreed that it made sense.

Over the next few days, the expedition systematically mapped an area of approximately 15 square kilm around the base camp.

They found three more sets of temporary shelters, all abandoned but clearly used.

In recent months, they discovered nearly invisible trails that connected these locations, forming a network of paths that someone who knew.

The area well could use to move quickly and unseen.

They also located two natural caves that showed signs of human occupation.

ashes from ancient campfires, tool marks on the walls, even some primitive drawings that resembled prehistoric rock art, but were clearly much more recent.

In one of these caves, the deepest and darkest of the two, they found something that made several men instinctively retreat.

Hanging from stelacтιтes near the entrance were animal skulls, dozens of them, deer, bears, coyotes, even some that appeared to be domestic animals like goats or pigs.

All had been meticulously cleaned, bleached by time, and were strung with vegetable fibers in arrangements that formed a kind of macob curtain.

They clearly served as a warning or territorial demarcation, a non-verbal message, but perfectly understandable.

This belongs to someone.

Stay away.

Henry pH๏τographed the skulls extensively.

He also ventured deeper into the cave, accompanied by Edmund and four soldiers carrying lanterns and torches.

The cave stretched for perhaps 50 m, gradually descending, the ceiling getting lower and lower until it was necessary to bend to continue.

And then, at the deepest point, they found a space that had been deliberately modified.

The floor was level, the walls had been smoothed with tools, and there was a raised platform built of flat stones stacked together.

on the platform more engraved symbols and around it concentric circles of small white stones identical to those they had seen in the clearing of the shelters.

But what drew the most attention was what was in the center of the platform.

It was an object wrapped in tanned leather tied with tendon ropes.

Henry hesitated before touching it.

There was something deeply wrong with that scene, something that challenged his rational confidence.

But he was an investigator and investigators needed to investigate.

Carefully he cut the ropes with his knife and unfolded the hide.

Inside were bones, human bones.

Not a complete skeleton, but specific parts.

A skull, both hands complete with all the small bones, still connected, and what appeared to be a sternum.

The bones were clean, bleached, treated with some kind of substance that made them look almost polished.

Edmund blessed himself.

The soldiers retreated a few steps.

Henry stayed on his knees and used his flashlight to look at the bones.

Even though he wasn’t a doctor, he had seen enough human bones at work to be able to tell them apart.

Based on how strong it was, the skull belonged to an adult, probably a man.

There was an old fracture on the right side of the head which had healed before the person died and there was something else.

They had seen this symbol many times before and it was carved directly into the front bone with a very fine tool.

The same set of intertwined lines were permanently etched into the bone.

With great care, Henry wrapped the bones again and chose to bring them back to base camp.

This was very important proof, maybe the clearest proof they had found that serious crimes were happening in.

They were mountains.

But it also brought up some scary questions.

The bones were very old.

They belonged to someone who had died many years or even decades ago.

They were not Burks or Burks.

It was clear who were they? How many other people had gone missing in that area over the years, and no one had looked into it properly? How many other sets of bones could be hidden in Appalachia’s many caves and far away valleys? Henry called another meeting when they got back to base camp that afternoon.

He talked about the discovery and his plan to end the expedition in 2 days.

He didn’t leave because he thought the mission was over, but because he had enough proof to support a much bigger operation that would need resources he didn’t have there.

He had to go back to Raleigh, tell state and maybe even federal officials what he had found, and plan the right response.

So, dozens or even hundreds of men might have to be brought in to work through the whole mountain area.

But not everyone agreed with what Henry did.

Since they found the warning at the stone shrine, Edmund Callaway had been quiet for most of the expedition.

He finally spoke up.

He said that if they waited weeks or months to plan a bigger expedition, the people who lived in those mountains would have time to disappear or hide all the evidence.

Now that they had men and tools, they had a chance to find those responsible and maybe even find out what happened to Nathaniel.

It was Burke and Ezra Whitlock.

In the event that the two men were not already ᴅᴇᴀᴅ, waiting would mean leaving them to their fate.

The argument went on for hours and got worse as it went on.

Some men, especially those with ties to the area and a sense of responsibility for the disappearances, stood by Edmund.

Others agreed with Henry, saying that they didn’t have the right tools or enough people to fight a whole community that knew the land much better than they did.

Reverend Yates made a different point of view, suggesting that maybe they should talk to each other instead of fighting, leaving messages that offered peace and reᴀssured them that they weren’t trying to be mean.

The young soldier named Robert Lee did something that no one else had fully thought of.

He found Nathaniel’s first piece of clothing.

He asked aloud if anyone had noticed that in all the days they had spent exploring the area, they hadn’t really seen a person.

All they had seen were empty signs of people being there, shelter, things left behind and notices in writing.

It seemed like whoever lived there was always one step ahead of them, watching and trying to stay away from them.

What did that mean? Were there so few that they didn’t want to start a fight? Perhaps there were so many that they could afford to run away and wait for the invaders to leave.

There were a lot of unknowns and rising tensions when the expedition spent its last planned night in the mountains.

No one knew the answers to these questions.

He had Henry.

They decided to go back the next morning, even though Edmund didn’t want to.

As a special investigator hired by the governor, he was legally in charge, and his decision would stand.

Edmund agreed to this, even though it was clear he didn’t want to.

As the men got ready for bed, some were happy to finally be leaving that place, while others were angry that they didn’t have any clear answers.

But the night had other ideas.

The night guards saw something around midnight.

strange lights.

Small, dim ones like flashlights or torches moving through the trees near the camp.

It wasn’t just one or two.

There were dozens of them in the distance, moving slowly toward the camp in a half circle.

All of the guards woke up right away.

Within minutes, all 25 men on the expedition were armed and standing around the tents and fires to protect them.

Henry pulled out a megaphone that he had brought just for this purpose and yelled into the dark.

His name was given as someone who works for the North Carolina government.

Added that they were not trying to hurt anyone and were just looking for information about two men who went missing.

Making sure no one would get hurt, he asked whoever was outside to come closer so they could talk.

His voice resounded through the valleys and off of the rock walls, making many layers of sound that faded into the nighttime silence.

There was no answer.

The lights kept getting closer slowly but surely.

Edmund suggested firing sH๏τs to scare off the air as a show of strength to stop any attack, but Henry refused.

They had no idea how many people were there or what their real goals were.

They were afraid that one sH๏τ would start a fight that they might not be able to win.

Instead, he told everyone to keep their weapons ready and point them downwards to feed the fires until they were burning at full power.

Then he told them to wait.

They would fight back if someone attacked, but they wouldn’t shoot first.

The light stopped about 100 m away from the outside of the camp.

They just stood there making a rough line through the trees across them.

The men on the expedition waited with their tense fingers on the triggers and their eyes trying to see shapes, numbers, or anything else that would give them an edge in battle.

It felt like hours went by.

The only sounds were the crackling of fire and the controlled breathing of men who were getting ready to fight.

Then there was a voice in the dark.

It wasn’t yelled, but it was carried in a way that made it clear to the camp.

The voice belonged to a man who spoke English with a strange old-fashioned accent, as if he were using words and pronunciations from a hundred years ago.

One sentence was all the voice said, “You need to leave.

” After a short pause, the voice said, “The man from the city you are looking for is now with his ancestors.

His guide was smart enough to run away while there was still time.

There will be no more warnings.

The lights went out just as quickly as they came on.

Everything was sucked back into the darkness of the forest all at once.

Henry yelled again, this time asking the person to come back, talk, and come to an agreement.

But they didn’t answer.

Up until dawn, the men waited in a defensive line, but nothing else happened.

When it finally got light enough to see, Henry and Edmund led a group of people to look for where the lights had been.

On the wet ground, they found a lot of bootprints.

Also, they found the bones of flames coming from torches made of branches wrapped in fabric and soaked in something flammable.

There was still some smoke, but no one was there.

Anyone who was there had gone deep into the forest, leaving only these small signs of his presence.

The group came down from the mountains that same morning.

There was no longer any doubt about staying.

Even Edmund agreed that things were too dangerous now.

They had a clear message from someone.

They should leave while they still can since Nathaniel Burke was already ᴅᴇᴀᴅ.

What this means is that the threat was clear.

They walked in a тιԍнт formation for 2 days on their way back to Marshall, always on the lookout, but nothing followed them.

It seemed like the people who lived in the heights just let them go when they started to go down.

When the expedition got to Marshall, there was a lot of noise right away.

People from all over the city gathered to greet them, eager for news, but the men’s faces did not show that they had good news.

Henry Blackwood went straight to Judge Morrison’s office with all of his things.

He showed him all the proof he had gathered, including the pH๏τos, the carefully wrapped human bones, the pieces of Nathaniel’s clothing, and his detailed notes.

He was accompanied by Edmund Callaway, and the two of them worked all day and night to write a full report for state officials.

There was a lot of important information in the report, which was sent to the state capital and kept there as official records.

There was nothing Henry tried to hide or play down that they had found.

He talked about the signs, the there were shrines, shelters, the cave with the bones, and the last night’s fight.

Their official conclusion was that the most remote parts of the Appalachians in Madison County were home to a small, isolated community.

This community may have been made up of members of religious groups that were pushed to the edges of society.

People in this community used human and animal bodies in rituals.

They violently defended their land against outsiders and they were responsible for the disappearance of at least two people in Nathaniel Burke and Ezra Whitlock.

In recent times, Henry suggested a full military operation that might include federal troops as well as the state militia.

He thought that a systematic search that could actually find and confront people living in the mountains would need at least 200 men.

the right tools for working in mountainous areas and several months of planning.

It was also suggested that anthropologists and doctors join the expedition to make sure that proper records were kept.

They should be kind to anyone they find and capture, especially children or people who might be being held against their will.

Express mail was used to send the report to Rally along with some very disturbing pictures and a letter from Henry to Governor Kitchen explaining how important the situation was.

It took 3 weeks to get the answer.

No one was happy when it finally got there.

The governor thanked Henry for his hard work and agreed that the results were very important.

The governor that the state’s budget did not have enough money for an operation of that size.

North Carolina was having its own economic problems at the time, so sending hundreds of men and a lot of money to explore remote mountains was not an option from a political point of view.

The governor instead suggested that Nathaniel Burke’s death be officially recorded as a accidental expedition death with undetermined causes since the body could not be found.

As for Ezra Whitlock, since he was from the area and seemed to have left on his own, there was no legal reason to keep looking for him.

While the governor agreed that there may be people living alone in those mountains, he also pointed out that it was not technically illegal to choose to live alone as long as there was no clear evidence of violent crimes against specific people.

Henry was very angry about the answer.

he put his life and the lives of other men had carefully written down proof of wrongdoing and was now being told that nothing would be done.

He thought about telling everyone about the case and putting his story in the newspapers, hoping that the public’s outrage would push the government to act.

Judge Morrison, who was older and smarter, told him not to do it, though.

If the case is made public, vigilantes and bounty hunters might invade those mountains, causing needless violence and putting innocent people in danger.

People who live close to the remote areas.

Henry reluctantly agreed that the official channels of government could not help him any further.

He stayed in Marshall for two more weeks and talked to older people to get their stories and try to get a better picture of the history of that area.

Finding out what he did was both interesting and scary.

People in their 80s and 90s remembered hearing stories about the people of the heights from their grandparents.

They if left alone, they weren’t seen as dangerous, but there were unspoken rules that everyone followed.

People didn’t go down certain trails or into certain valleys, and if someone showed that they wanted privacy, it was taken seriously.

Another woman who had to be at least 80 years old, told Henry something that he thought was very telling.

One time when she was a child, maybe around 1840, she saw a group of people coming down from the mountains to trade in the city.

They brought skins from animals, herbs used for medicine, and beautiful wooden objects.

They dressed very old-fashioned for that time and spoke English with a strange accent.

They did business quickly and silently, never talking about anything other than what was needed for the deal.

After doing business, they disappeared back into the mountains.

When she was young, this happened once or twice a year.

Over time, it happened less often until it stopped happening at all.

All of Henry wrote was.

Write this down carefully.

There were more pieces coming together in my theory.

It’s possible that these people weren’t naturally violent criminals.

They might have just chosen to live alone and reacted defensively when their privacy was invaded.

Nathaniel Burke crossed a line when he was exploring his sacred or important sites and taking things from the stone shrine.

He should not have, and his death should serve as a warning to others who might think about doing the same.

It didn’t.

It didn’t explain what happened, but it did give us a way to think about it.

Henry never found out what would happen to Ezra Whitlock.

The tour guide just vanished, and no one in Marshall or any other nearby town ever saw them again.

It could have gone either way.

He either ran away when he realized he was in danger and started a new life far away, or he was connected to the people who lived in the mountains in some way and went back to live with them.

Henry had doubts about the second one.

Ezra also knew the way.

Okay, he knew not to go there.

He tried to warn Nathaniel.

Perhaps he was a link between two worlds, living on the edge of both.

And when that line was crossed, he just went back to the side where he belonged.

At the end of August 1911, Henry Blackwood left Marshall.

He went back to rally and kept working as a special investigator.

But the Nathaniel Berg case followed him around for the rest of his work life.

He carefully arranged all of his papers, pH๏τos, and notes in boxes that were eventually after he died in 1938 and gave it to the state archives.

These papers are still there, and any researcher who wants to look them up can.

They are a silent record of one of the strangest and unsolved cases in North Carolina history.

For an extra 15 years, Edmund Callaway stayed as sheriff of Madison County.

He never again planned trips to those mountains.

In fact, he became one of the strongest supporters of leaving some areas untouched at all costs.

It was when young explorers and adventurers came to the city who wanted to map out remote areas, Edmund strongly warned them against it, sometimes even exaggerating the area’s natural dangers to keep them away.

In those mountains, he saw something that completely changed the way he saw things.

There was more than just fear.

There was also a kind of reluctant respect for the will of a group of people to stay completely separate from modern life.

In the years after Nathaniel Burke went missing, there were sometimes other events.

A hunter who didn’t are two college students who got lost on a hike in 1923 and were never found.

They were on an expedition in 1917.

Edmund looked into it a little bit each time, but he always came to the same conclusion.

People went where they shouldn’t have, and the mountains caught them.

He never talked about the isolated community again in public.

He didn’t tell anyone else about that information, only trusted successors and people he thought needed to know for public safety.

the railroad, the company that hired Nathaniel Burke, gave up on its plans to build more lines through that part of Appalachia in the end.

Officially, the decision was made because of cost concerns and the toughness of the terrain.

But internal company documents found by historians many years later suggest that the real reason was Nathaniel’s disappearance and the scary report that Henry Blackwood gave to company executives in secret.

Sending more men to a place was just not worth the risk where they couldn’t be sure they would be safe.

As the rest of North Carolina moved into the 20th century, this part of the state stayed stuck in the past without any new roads or railroads.

Over the years, the stories about Nathaniel Burke and what happened in the winter of 1911 became wellknown in the area.

There were lost details, exaggerations, and even stories that were made up.

Some people think Nathaniel just got lost and died from being out in the open.

Some people say that he was attacked by wild animals.

And for those who knew the in the darker parts of the story, he had found secrets that the mountains were very protective of, and he had paid the ultimate price for being interested.

The story was told a little differently by each generation, but the main idea stayed the same.

Some parts of those mountains were off limits to outsiders, and bad things were in store for those who didn’t listen.

Nathaniel Burke’s diary eventually got lost in Madison County.

In 1962, it was bought by a private collector of historical documents.

This collector who was interested in history tried to plan his own trip to find the places written about in the diary.

He got six men together who were all experienced mountain climbers and explorers, and they spent two weeks in the mountains in the summer of 1964.

They found some of the general areas Nathaniel had told them about, but the landmarks had changed since the last time they saw them more than 50 years ago.

The ground had been changed by landslides, and plants had grown over old structures, making it impossible to find the stone shrine or the bone cave.

Along with that, they didn’t find any signs of recent human activity.

It looked like the forest had taken everything back in.

But during that 1964 trip, something important happened that needs to be talked about.

The collector and his friends heard something the night before they went down.

They were camping in a valley that they thought was close to where Nathaniel had made his last camp.

What Henry Blackwood’s expedition heard were not the sounds of fighting, but rather sounds of something more subtle.

Corners, people.

They could hear voices singing in a language they didn’t understand coming from somewhere in the mountains that they couldn’t quite pin down.

The noise was there for about 15 minutes and then went away into the night silence.

When they got down in the morning, they all agreed not to tell anyone else about it.

But in his diary, the collector wrote, “There is something alive in these mountains besides animals and trees, something old that chose to stay hidden.

And maybe that’s for the best.

With the rise of digital mapping and satellite technology in recent years, almost the whole surface of the Earth in the United States has been pH๏τographed and mapped.

Some researchers look at pictures of the more remote parts of Madison County to see if they can find any strange things or man-made structures that might support Nathaniel Burke’s story.

Some people say they found strange rock formations, clearings that look like they were planned, and even what might be, paths or trails that connect areas that aren’t easy to get to.

But images from space can be wrong.

Structures can be seen in shadows.

Natural formations mimic human design and no one really knows what to look for.

In reality, that part of Appalachia is still one of the least populated and least developed parts of North Carolina.

There are whole valleys that people today rarely go into.

Dense forests that let almost no light reach the ground.

There are caves that haven’t been fully explored or mapped yet.

It’s simple to picture.

That thing or person could hide there for many years if they really wanted to.

The mountains are very big and people still only live on the edges and in the valleys that are easy to get to.

The heights are mostly uninhabited.

What did Nathaniel Burke really do? Was he killed by a small group of people who thought that using him for profit was disrespectful to holy places? Did he lose his way and die in the elements? Was his body later found by people who practiced and ritualized? Odd habits we don’t get.

Or is there a completely different reason that none of the investigators who came after Henry Blackwood, Edmund Callaway, or themselves have been able to think of? We still don’t have complete answers more than a hundred years later.

All we have are pieces of evidence, secondhand accounts, and that silent diary with its last unsettling entry about footsteps at night.

We can learn something important about the United States in the early 1900s from the case of Nathaniel Burke.

as there were still blank spots on the map.

As much as we’d like to believe that the country was fully mapped, fully civilized, and fully known at that time, there were places where the federal, state, or even local government couldn’t really help.

Communities that lived their own lives not connected to the national story, following their own rules, keeping their own traditions, and keeping their secrets with a fervor that might seem fanatical to outsiders.

But in their own cultural terms, that made perfect sense.

When we think back over more than 100 years, it’s easy to judge those who didn’t solve the case.

Just why didn’t the governor send more troops? Why did Edmund Callaway give up looking in the end? Henry Blackwood should have been more insistent, but they lived in a different world with different priorities and ideas about what was possible or desirable.

They may have made choices that made sense at the time.

Or maybe they just came across something that was too much for them to handle and they chose the easiest way out.

The Appalachians have always been there, unaffected by the human dramas that happen on their slopes and in their valleys.

The seasons change, trees grow, and streams keep running over old rocks.

And maybe there are still descendants of the people Nathaniel Burke found somewhere in those heights.

Maybe not.

Maybe time and the inevitable growth of modern society finally they were caught and either split up, became one big group, or stopped being a separate group altogether.

We’re not sure.

The fact that we don’t know might also be right.

There are some mysteries that should stay mysteries.

We should leave some stories with open endings that make us wonder.

Nathaniel Burke, a 32-year-old ctographer from Richmond, left in March 1911 to map routes through Appalachia and never came back.

His diary was found.

People found his tools, pieces of his clothes, showed up in strange places, but the man has disappeared completely, being sucked up by mountains that are as protective of their secrets as a locked vault.

When he tried to make a map of the unknown, he became a part of it.

A story told in the dark at night as a warning about the risks of being too curious and a reminder that even in the modern world, there are still lines we might not want to cross.

The terrible story of Nathaniel Burke, a man who looked for answers deep in the the Appalachins and only found more questions.

If you were interested in this case or the dark mountains and their old secrets, please help us keep finding these stories that have been lost.

you can make sure you don’t miss our next videos where we look into historical mysteries that time has tried to erase.

If this trip through the North Carolina mountains keeps you interested all the way to the end, please click like and let us know in the comments if you think there are still places in the United States where people live in remote areas that are cut off from the rest of the world.

We care about what you think and we love reading all of your comments.